← Analysis Breakdowns A real competitive marketing analysis

Remodeling Competitive Marketing Analysis: What We Found and What We Recommended

This remodeling competitive marketing analysis is a sanitized walkthrough of real research Coast333 conducted for a young remodeling contractor in North Central Florida. Every job in progress had come from a referral. Online, the company was starting from zero, and its paid leads had not produced a single job.

Request your Competitive Marketing Analysis
The business
A residential remodeling contractor taking on kitchens, baths and whole homes
The question
Referrals keep us busy for now. How do we find remodel clients who do not already know us?
What this is
A diagnosis and a set of recommendations. Not a record of results.

This is a real Competitive Marketing Analysis with the business taken out of it. The company’s name, its owner, its location, its job values, margins and spending, and its competitors have been generalized or withheld. The findings themselves are unchanged.

The same owner runs an established fence and deck company, and both businesses were reviewed in one session in December 2025. The fence analysis is published as its own breakdown. Nothing here describes implementation, and no outcome is claimed. These recommendations were presented, not executed.

The situation in twenty seconds

Business
A remodeling contractor focused on kitchens, bathrooms and whole-home remodels, with some concrete work. Any remodel is welcome; a whole house is ideal.
Capacity
Four remodels in progress, all due to finish within about two weeks. The owner could manage eight to ten at a time, each running about six weeks.
Market
Homeowners in and around a mid-sized metro area in North Central Florida, competing with established kitchen, bath and design-build firms.
Marketing in place
A few months of Facebook ads, since paused. A website built by an outside developer. A Google Business Profile that had been set up but never worked on.
Main challenge
Building a pipeline that does not depend on referrals alone, without paying for leads that never turn into jobs.
Constraint
The owner handles every remodel lead himself, and the business did not have full access to the domain its website runs on.
Areas reviewed
Google Business Profile and reviews · geo-grid map rankings for four remodeling searches · website rankings and traffic · three local competitors · city-name remodeling searches · remodeling keyword costs · Facebook lead quality

What the business was actually dealing with

The remodeling company was newer than the owner’s fence business, and so far it had run on referrals. Referrals are the easiest leads a remodeler gets. The homeowner already trusts the contractor before the first call, and the owner said he rarely failed to win one. All four remodels in progress had come that way.

But referrals arrive when they arrive. All four projects were due to finish within about two weeks, and the owner wanted eight to ten running at once. He had tried Facebook ads to fill the gap. The leads came in, but almost none of them were real, and none became jobs.

Online, there was little to build on yet. The website ranked for three searches and drew no measurable traffic. The Google profile had no reviews and did not rank for any remodeling search it was scanned for. As with the fence site, the developer who built the website controlled the domain, and the owner had not been able to get access to it.

What this remodeling competitive marketing analysis examined

For a remodeler starting online from scratch, the questions were simple: where do strangers look for a remodeler, who do they find, and what does it cost to be found?

  • Local map rankings

    Geo-grid scans of 49 points each for “construction companies,” “bathroom remodel,” “kitchen remodel” and “home remodeling.”

  • Google Business Profile

    Reviews, categories, photos and activity, and where the profile’s location sits relative to the market.

  • Website footprint

    Every search term the site ranked for, its estimated traffic over two years and its domain authority.

  • Three local competitors

    A kitchen and bath remodeler, a kitchen and bath design firm, and a design-build remodeler, all in the same city.

  • Search costs

    About 30,000 remodeling searches with estimated cost per click, plus the city-name searches the competitors rank for.

  • Paid social

    The owner’s own Facebook campaign for concrete work, reviewed on screen, from leads received to jobs won.

What 127 Facebook leads turned into

The owner had run Facebook ads for the construction company’s concrete work for about six weeks. On the call, he walked through what happened to the leads, step by step.

The ads did their job. They produced leads. They just did not produce customers.

127

form leads from a six-week Facebook campaign. Jobs won from them: none.

Where the four remodels in progress came from

4 of 4referrals. None from paid ads.

  1. 127Form leads receivedFrom the six-week campaign
  2. About87With real contact detailsAbout 40 were spam or fake
  3. About40Genuinely interestedAbout half of the real leads
  4. About10Worth quotingThe owner’s estimate
  5. 0Jobs wonNone of the quoted leads went ahead

Stages are the owner’s estimates while reviewing his ad account. “About 87” subtracts the roughly 40 spam or fake entries from 127 (Coast333 calculation); the owner put it at about 80. Bar lengths are proportional to the counts.

About a third of the leads were spam: fake email addresses and disconnected phone numbers. Of the real ones, about half were not seriously in the market. Around ten were worth quoting, and none of them went ahead. Every one of those leads still had to be called, checked or quoted before it could be ruled out.

None of this means the ads were badly made. The copy was good. The trouble is that Facebook puts ads in front of people who are scrolling, not people looking for a contractor. For a remodel, the more reliable signal is someone who types “kitchen remodel” into Google, or who finds a nearby company with good reviews on the map. At the time of the review, the company could not yet be found in either place.

The competitive landscape

The three competitors the owner named are well established. Each one owns a different part of the city’s remodeling searches.

Search visibility at the time of the review. Figures are third-party tool estimates; visits are monthly. Domain authority is a 0–100 third-party score, not a Google metric.
Measure The company Kitchen and bath remodeler A Kitchen and bath design firm B Design-build remodeler C
Ranked keywords 31961,800361
Page-one keywords 05540850
Estimated organic visits 06472,200330
Domain authority 291811

Searches that name the city: who shows up

Selected city-name remodeling searches from the research data. Positions are each company’s best placement; “In the map” means it appeared in Google’s local results for that search. The city’s name is withheld. Volumes are local monthly estimates; cost per click is the tool’s estimate.
Search Monthly searches Cost per click The company Remodeler A Design firm B Design-build C
“bathroom remodel” + city + state210$21.70Not in the top 1001Website position 1MapIn the map resultsMapIn the map results
“bathroom remodeling” + city260$20.81Not in the top 1001Website position 1MapIn the map results4Website position 4
city + “bath remodel”140$19.48Not in the top 1001Website position 1MapIn the map results3Website position 3
“kitchen remodeling” + city170$9.26Not in the top 100MapIn the map resultsMapIn the map results1Website position 1
“kitchen remodeling” + city + state110$8.3680Website position 801Website position 1MapIn the map resultsMapIn the map results
“kitchen renovation” + city + state140$4.77Not in the top 100MapIn the map results1Website position 1MapIn the map results
city + “home renovations”390$11.62Not in the top 1009Website position 917Website position 174Website position 4
“home remodeling” + city + state320$9.66Not in the top 1008Website position 821Website position 216Website position 6
“home additions” + city70—17Website position 1745Website position 4567Website position 673Website position 3
  • MapIn the map results
  • 5Website position
  • —Not in the top 100

The kitchen and bath remodeler owns the bathroom searches. It held first place for most city-name bathroom and kitchen remodeling searches, with a page for each service. These are also the most expensive searches in the market. Locally, bathroom remodeling clicks were estimated at about $20 each.

The design firm’s traffic is mostly inspiration. Its 2,200 estimated monthly visits come largely from idea articles, such as kitchen lighting ideas, rather than from people hiring. It still appeared in the map for most kitchen and bath city searches, which is where its local customers come from.

The design-build firm owns “renovation” and “additions.” It ranked best of the three for the broad home-remodeling and renovation searches, and third for home additions in the city.

The company had one foothold. Its home additions page ranked 17th for the city search, ahead of two of the three established competitors. A page about one specific service, in one specific place, was already the right model.

What was already working

Starting from zero online is not the same as starting from zero.

  • Referrals that close

    Every remodel in progress came from word of mouth, and the owner said he rarely failed to win a referred job.

  • A list of happy past clients

    The owner estimated he could gather about 20 Google reviews from past remodel clients within a month. That is enough to change the profile’s standing quickly.

  • A sister business to learn from

    The fence company had already shown what a worked-on profile can do. The same habits carry straight over.

  • The right page model

    The home additions page outranked two established competitors for its city search. More pages like it are the plan.

  • Room to grow

    With capacity for eight to ten remodels at once and four finishing, every good lead had a place on the schedule.

  • An owner who knows his numbers

    Typical job values and margins were at hand, so any paid campaign can be judged against what a remodel is actually worth.

The five opportunities we identified

The review resolved into five themes. For each: what we found, why it mattered, and what we recommended.

Opportunity 01

A Google profile with no reviews, placed outside the market

What we found

The profile had no reviews and had not been worked on. In all four scans, every one of the 49 points ranked outside the top 20. The scans were centered on the profile’s map location, a rural area about 20 miles from the city where the competitors rank. So even a well-built profile would have started far from most of the people searching.

Each of the four scansTop 20 at 0 of 49 points

0 of 196scan points in the top 20, across all four searches

  • “Construction companies”
  • “Bathroom remodel”
  • “Kitchen remodel”
  • “Home remodeling”
Why it mattered

Google ranks local results by relevance, distance and prominence. A profile placed far from the searcher, with no reviews, scores poorly on two of the three. And homeowners choosing someone to take apart their kitchen read reviews closely.

What we recommended

Confirm the profile’s address and service area. A contractor who works at customers’ homes can hide its address and list the areas it serves, including the city. Then build reviews from past clients, a few a week rather than all at once. Add photos of finished projects, list each remodeling service, and post every week. Expect this to be a slower build than the fence profile, and measure it with a monthly grid scan. More on our local SEO work.

Opportunity 02

A website that ranked for three searches

What we found

The site ranked for three searches: home additions in the city (17th), construction in the city (52nd) and kitchen remodeling in the city (80th). Its estimated organic traffic had been zero for two years, and its domain authority was 2 out of 100. The owner said some content named places that had nothing to do with his work. He had also been unable to get access to the domain to set up company email.

Why it mattered

Remodeling clients compare contractors carefully, and the website is where they look at past work. It is also where every search ad sends people. A site with no service pages gives Google nothing to rank. And if the business does not control the domain, anything invested in the site builds value for someone else.

What we recommended

Secure the domain first, or move to one the business owns while the site is still young and has little to lose. Then build one page per service, kitchens, bathrooms, whole-home remodels and additions, each with real project photos and the areas actually served. Put a call button and a short form at the top of each page. More on website design and optimization.

Opportunity 03

Paying for remodel searches instead of social scrolls

What we found

The company had never run Google search ads. Remodeling clicks cost more than fence clicks, but they come from people actively planning a project:

  • Kitchen remodel$7.89
  • Whole house remodelThe owner’s ideal job$8.29
  • Home remodeling near me$9.81
  • Kitchen remodel near me$11.85
  • Shower remodel$13.31
  • Bathroom remodel$13.67
  • Bathroom remodel near me$18.98
Coast333 planning assumptions

We assume about one in ten clicks becomes a call or form. That puts a kitchen remodel lead at about $79, a home remodeling lead at about $98 and a bathroom remodel lead at about $137. For leads from strangers, we plan on about one in five becoming a signed job, far below a referral’s close rate. That works out to roughly $400 to $700 in ad cost per remodel won. These are planning figures from national estimates, not results.

Why it mattered

Against the value of a remodel, those figures are modest, and every click comes from someone looking for exactly this work. That is the opposite of the Facebook campaign, which produced plenty of cheap leads and no jobs. The planning close rate matters too. Leads from strangers need quoting and follow-up, and judging them by referral standards would make the campaign look worse than it is.

What we recommended

Run standard Google search ads for kitchen, bathroom and whole-home remodeling, limited to the area the business serves, in an ad account of its own. Track calls and forms from day one, and record which leads become jobs. Start with the searches that cost less per lead, and add bathroom searches once quoting and follow-up are working well. More on paid advertising for lead generation.

Opportunity 04

Facebook budget better saved for later

What we found

The Facebook campaign brought in 127 leads, about a third of them spam, and no jobs. The ads had been paused. Both businesses’ campaigns appeared to share one ad account, which means the platform was learning from fence buyers and remodel buyers at the same time.

Why it mattered

Social ads for a remodeler work best on people who already know the company, such as those who have visited the website or seen its projects. With no search traffic yet, there was nobody to remind.

What we recommended

Keep cold Facebook campaigns off for now. Once search ads and the profile are bringing visitors, use social ads to show project videos and photos to people who have already visited the site. Give each business its own ad account so each audience is learned separately. More on paid social advertising.

Opportunity 05

A full schedule that was about to empty

What we found

All four remodels in progress were due to finish within about two weeks, and each new remodel takes weeks to plan and sell. Referrals had kept the schedule full so far, but nothing was coming in reliably behind them.

Current state

  • Every job from referrals
  • No reviews to show strangers
  • No search presence
  • Lead sources not tracked

Opportunity

  • Referrals plus search, so a quiet month is not empty
  • Past clients’ reviews on the profile
  • Search ads for near-term leads, the profile for the long term
  • Every lead tagged by source and outcome
Why it mattered

A remodeler who can see the next two months of work can plan crews and buying. One who depends on referrals alone has busy months and quiet ones with nothing to smooth them out.

What we recommended

Start both channels at once. Search ads can produce leads within weeks of launch. The profile and website take months, so starting them now means they are working when the ads’ first results are in. Ask every referral client for a review and permission to photograph the finished project.

What we recommended doing first

The order starts with what costs nothing and takes longest to build, then adds paid search on a website the business controls.

  1. 1

    Fix the profile’s location and start reviews

    Confirm the address and service area, then add past clients’ reviews a few at a time, with project photos.

    It is free, it takes the longest to build, and remodel clients check reviews first.

  2. 2

    Secure the domain and build service pages

    Kitchens, bathrooms, whole-home remodels and additions, each with real photos and a clear way to call.

    Search ads need somewhere good to send people, and the business should own it.

  3. 3

    Launch Google search ads for remodeling

    Kitchen and whole-home searches first, then bathrooms, with call tracking and an account of its own.

    The fastest way to reach homeowners actively planning a remodel.

  4. 4

    Add social retargeting later

    Project photos and videos shown to people who have already visited the site.

    Social works for a remodeler once there is an audience that already knows the name.

Do this week, whatever the budget

Check the address and service area on the Google profile. Send review requests to three or four past remodel clients. Upload before-and-after photos of the four projects about to finish. Ask the developer in writing for control of the domain. Start a simple spreadsheet that records every lead’s source and whether it became a job.

What other remodelers can take from this

Six things from this review apply to most remodeling contractors.

  • Count jobs, not leads

    A campaign that produces a hundred leads and no jobs is not cheaper than one that produces ten leads and two jobs.

  • Referrals are not a pipeline

    They are the best leads you will get, but they do not arrive on a schedule.

  • Your profile’s location matters

    If your profile sits far from your customers, list a service area and make sure Google knows where you work.

  • Ask past clients now

    A handful of reviews from real projects changes how a profile reads to a stranger. Spread them out.

  • One page per service

    A page about home additions in your city can outrank established firms. A home page about everything rarely does.

  • Plan for a lower close rate

    Leads from strangers close less often than referrals. Budget for it, so a working campaign is not cut too early.

How Coast333 approaches remodelers starting out online

A new remodeling company does not need every channel at once. It needs a profile that can be found, a website it owns, and paid search pointed at homeowners who are ready to start. This analysis was built that way, alongside a separate plan for the owner’s fence business, with each business kept in its own accounts.

This analysis was researched and presented by a senior strategist with long experience in search. You can see published results from Google Business Profile work in our Google Business Profile optimization case study (results from a different business).

Related resources

Browse all analysis breakdowns →

See what we would find in your marketing

Coast333 runs a complimentary Competitive Marketing Analysis for businesses that want a clear read on their own marketing, their competitors and the opportunities in front of them. It is the same research process described on this page.

  1. 01You fill out a short form with your details, and we reach out to arrange a conversation.
  2. 02We talk through your business, your goals and who you consider your competitors.
  3. 03Our strategy team conducts the research on you and on those competitors.
  4. 04We walk you through everything we found, in detail, and answer questions.
Request your Competitive Marketing Analysis

The first conversation gives us the context we need to prepare the analysis. Our strategy team then conducts the research and walks you through what we find. The Competitive Marketing Analysis is complimentary, with no obligation attached.

Method and sourcing

Research for this analysis used third-party keyword, traffic and rank-tracking tools, geo-grid local rank scans captured on December 29, 2025, and direct review of the company’s website, Google Business Profile and Facebook campaign. Context, including capacity, lead sources, the Facebook lead breakdown and the website arrangement, was supplied by the owner during the review.

Figures described as estimates are third-party tool estimates. City-name search volumes are local; generic search volumes and costs per click are national. The planning costs per lead and per job are our own calculations from those estimates and stated assumptions. The distance between the scan center and the city is our measurement from the scan maps. Grid values match the scanning tool’s averages.